As Migrants Flow In, More Europeans Question Open Borders | WYPR

As Migrants Flow In, More Europeans Question Open Borders

Oct 28, 2015
Originally published on October 28, 2015 10:41 pm

Germany and Poland may not share a common language or currency, but they do share an open border.

Both are among the 26 European nations in what's known as the Schengen Area, and getting from one to the other is as simple as crossing a bridge over the Oder River by car or on foot.

No one has asked to see passports at this border crossing, 60 miles east of Berlin, since Poland joined the European Union in 2004. Nor does anyone check to see whether travelers are obeying custom rules.

But the arrival of thousands of migrants daily in Europe's Schengen countries has many European governments complaining the open-border policy is being abused.

A few leaders, like Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban, have erected fences or otherwise sealed their borders with fellow EU states in protest. On Wednesday, Austria and Slovenia announced their own plans to build fences along parts of their borders.

One of dozens of Germans walking to the Polish side on a recent chilly morning is Stefan Rohde, 55, from Berlin.

"Isn't it wonderful? I think it's great we can move so freely," he says.

Prices are far cheaper in Poland, so Rohde crosses the river to the Polish town of Slubice once a month to buy cigarettes and other items for his elderly neighbors.

Fellow Berlin resident Manuela Bayer also shops in Slubice. She says that was a lot harder to do during the Communist era, even though East Germany and Poland were allies. She says back then, she had to wait 45 minutes for surly border guards to check her passport.

Bayer says it would be ridiculous to introduce such border controls between the countries now.

More Calls For Border Checks

But most Germans on the bridge this day tell me they'd welcome renewed border checks. One is Burkhard, 56, from Frankfurt-an-der-Oder on the German side of the bridge, who refuses to give his last name.

He complains about thieves and vandals he says come to his town from Poland. He says border abuses are even worse in southern Germany, where many migrants have been arriving.

While member countries are allowed to close internal Schengen borders temporarily, senior European leaders criticize what's happening now as self-serving and warn it could cause lasting damage to the EU bloc.

Pierre Vimont of Carnegie Europe is an adviser to EU President Donald Tusk. Vimont says he doubts European countries could get rid of their open borders permanently even if they want to.

"It's not all that sure that we would be able to manage the way we used to, 20 or 30 years ago," he says. "Now we have so much in common trade, industry, that if we go back to national domestic borders, it would be a total new landscape and we would need to find totally new ways of managing these borders."

For now, European leaders of the Schengen countries appear eager to keep their open-border arrangement. Those who attended an emergency summit in Brussels last weekend agreed to increase funding and send police to improve controls on the zone's external borders.

Copyright 2017 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

ARI SHAPIRO, HOST:

Open borders have been a key part of European identity for decades. People freely cross from one country to another without passport controls or checkpoints - at least they used to. Now governments are tightening controls, reacting to migrants coming from the Middle East and Africa. Earlier today, Austria said it plans to build fences along parts of its Southern frontier. Slovenia announced it's considering similar action. NPR's Soraya Sarhaddi Nelson reports that a growing number of Germans are also ready to give up on open borders.

SORAYA SARHADDI NELSON, BYLINE: Germany and Poland may not share a common language or currency, but they do share, but they do share an open border. Both countries are part of what's known as the Schengen Area, and getting from one to the other is as simple as crossing this bridge over the river Oder by car or on foot. No one has asked to see passports at this border crossing 60 miles east of Berlin since Poland joined the EU in 2004, nor does anyone check to see if travelers are obeying custom rules. One of dozens of Germans walking to the Polish side on a recent chilly morning is Stefan Rohde.

STEFAN ROHDE: (Speaking German).

NELSON: The 55-year-old from Berlin says, "isn't it wonderful. I think it's great we can move so freely." Prices are far cheaper in Poland, so Rohde crosses the river to the Polish town of Slubice once a month to buy cigarettes and other items for his elderly neighbors. Fellow Berlin resident Manuela Bayer also shops in Slubice.

MANUELA BAYER: (Speaking German).

NELSON: She says that was a lot harder to do during the communist era even though back then, East Germany and Poland were allies. She says she used to have to wait 45 minutes for surly border guards to check her passport.

BAYER: (Speaking German).

NELSON: Bayer says it would be ridiculous to introduce such border controls between the countries now. But most other Germans on the bridge this day tell me they'd welcome renewed border checks.

BURKHARD: (Speaking German).

NELSON: One is 56- year-old Burkhard from Frankfurt an der Oder on the German side of the bridge, who refuses to give his last name. He complains about thieves and vandals he says come to his town from Poland. He says Schengen border abuses are even worse in Southern Germany.

The arrival of thousands of migrants daily in Schengen countries, like these people who recently walked from Hungary to Austria, has many European governments complaining the open border policy is being abused. A few leaders, like Hungarian prime minister Viktor Orban, have erected fences or otherwise sealed their borders with fellow EU states in protest.

While member countries are allowed to close internal Schengen borders on a temporary basis, senior European leaders criticize what's happening now as self-serving and warn it could cause lasting damage to the EU block. Pierre Vimont of Carnegie is an advisor to EU president Donald Tusk. He says he doubts European countries could get rid of their open boarders permanently, even if they want to.

PIERRE VIMONT: It's not all that sure that we will be able to manage the way we used to 20 or 30 years ago. Now we have so much in common - trade, industry, whatsoever - that if we go back to national domestic borders, it would be a totally new landscape, and we would need to find totally new ways of managing these borders.

NELSON: For now, Schengen leaders say they wants to continue their open border arrangements. Those who went to an emergency summit in Brussels last weekend agreed to increase funding and send police to improve controls on the zone's external borders. Soraya Sarhaddi Nelson, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.